THE CHEAPSKATES CLUB
  • Home
  • Join the Club!
    • Twenty Reasons to Join the Cheapskates Club
    • Gift Memberships
  • About Us
    • Cath's Story
    • Ask Cath
    • Glossary of Cheapskating Terms
  • Forum
    • Current Forum Discussions
    • How to Use the Member Forum
  • Inspiration
    • Getting Started
    • Handmade Christmas Central >
      • Handmade Christmas 2025 is about to start
    • 31 Days of MOO Index
    • Articles
    • Back to Basics >
      • Back to Basics
      • Back to Basics Index
    • Housekeeping Routines
    • Budget Renovations
    • Saving Stories
  • SAVING REVOLUTION
    • 2025 Saving Revolution Index
    • Saving Revolution Resources
  • Recipes
    • Recipe File Index
    • Meal Plans
    • Add a Recipe
    • $300 a Month Food Challenge >
      • $300 a Month Food Challenge
      • The $300 a Month Food Challenge Forum
  • Newsletters
    • Newsletters 2025
  • Saving Money
    • Bill Paying System
    • Cheapskates Tip Store
    • Tip Sheets
    • Top Tip Competition
  • Contact
    • Changing Details
    • Help Files

31 Days of MOO No. 14 Cath's Bagel Seasoning

​I'd been hearing about Everything But the Bagel Seasoning for ages; it was all over the socials and my curiosity was tweaked. 

As soon as I saw the price, my curiosity died. But the Cheapskater in me stood tall, and I checked the ingredients on the pack - I had everything except the flaked sea salt (have you seen the price of that stuff? The cheapest is $6 a box, the most expensive I could find in my supermarket was $10! For salt!). 

I started digging around, looking at recipes, trying to find common ingredients amongst them all, and the other optional ingredients. Then I took out the suggestions I knew we wouldn’t enjoy, played around with the ratios of the other ingredients and this is what I came up with.

And it is good! We love it, not only on bagels, but sprinkled over bread rolls although so far our favourite is to add it to the dough for tortillas and have seasoned tortillas, and they are so good, everyone wants more every time I do a batch.

Ingredients: 
6 tbsp sesame seeds
2 tbsp dried onion flakes
2 tbsp garlic granules
2 tbsp poppy seeds
2 tbsp flaked sea salt*

Gently toast the sesame seeds over a very low heat until they just start to change colour. This doesn't take very long, so watch so they don't burn. Tip them into a bowl and swirl around so they cool. When they are completely cooled, add the remaining ingredients. I put everything in a repurposed Vegemite jar with a screw top lid, put the lid on and then give it all a good shake to mix it up. Store your bagel seasoning on the shelf in the pantry, with the lid on. 

Notes:
The original recipe I based this on used white and black sesame seeds at a ratio of 2:1. Black sesame seeds are available from Hindustan Imports.

I don't have flaked sea salt, it is too expensive. I use 2 tablespoons rock sea salt and use the mortar and pestle to break it down to slightly smaller rocks. You could use table salt, but you'll need to remember to give the jar a good shake every time you use to as the salt will sink to the bottom of the jar. 
Index
Day 13
Day 15

About Cheapskates

Getting Started

Tools & Guides

Follow Us

Cath's Story
You Really Can Live on One Income
Join the Club!
Site Information
Contact
Begin here
Newsletter Archive
Journal Archive
$300 a Month Food Challenge
Forum
Cheapskates Tip Store
Cheapskates Recipe File
Tip Sheets
Facebook
YouTube

Copyright ©2001 - 2025 The Cheapskates Club, All Rights Reserved
  • Home
  • Join the Club!
    • Twenty Reasons to Join the Cheapskates Club
    • Gift Memberships
  • About Us
    • Cath's Story
    • Ask Cath
    • Glossary of Cheapskating Terms
  • Forum
    • Current Forum Discussions
    • How to Use the Member Forum
  • Inspiration
    • Getting Started
    • Handmade Christmas Central >
      • Handmade Christmas 2025 is about to start
    • 31 Days of MOO Index
    • Articles
    • Back to Basics >
      • Back to Basics
      • Back to Basics Index
    • Housekeeping Routines
    • Budget Renovations
    • Saving Stories
  • SAVING REVOLUTION
    • 2025 Saving Revolution Index
    • Saving Revolution Resources
  • Recipes
    • Recipe File Index
    • Meal Plans
    • Add a Recipe
    • $300 a Month Food Challenge >
      • $300 a Month Food Challenge
      • The $300 a Month Food Challenge Forum
  • Newsletters
    • Newsletters 2025
  • Saving Money
    • Bill Paying System
    • Cheapskates Tip Store
    • Tip Sheets
    • Top Tip Competition
  • Contact
    • Changing Details
    • Help Files